The concept of local justice was dealt a fatal blow from 2010 when the then Lord Chancellor Kenneth Clarke proudly announced that he was the first Cabinet member in the new government to have reduced his budget; not just a reduction but a mammoth 23.8% off previously projected spending. Much of that was savings owing to his determination to close many magistrates courts and sell the buildings. Half of all these courts had been sold by 2019/20. Further distancing from being local in administration came in April 2011 when HM Courts Service (HMCS) became HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS). That was when HMCS merged with the Tribunals Service to form a single agency of the Ministry of Justice, responsible for administering the criminal, civil and family courts and tribunals in England and Wales (plus some non-devolved tribunals in Scotland and Northern Ireland).
Local Justice Areas were created under the Courts Act 2003 and have existed since 2005. They were repeatedly merged with the most recent major merger taking effect on 1 April 2017. Section 45 of the Judicial Review and Courts Act 2022 says that local justice areas are abolished and the Act received Royal Assent in April 2022. But that section was not in force at Royal Assent and it takes effect only when a commencement date is appointed. The MoJ’s consultation response, updated 24 March 2026, still says LJAs will be abolished when section 45 is commenced. This is just another signpost of government intentions.
I have posted previously that what statistics the MOJ does not publish can be as interesting as those they do. A case in point is the number of qualified legal advisors employed in the magistrates courts system. They are as essential to the current system as the magistrates themselves. Without them the system collapses. It is thought that currently there are 1,200 according to the House of Commons Justice Committee. Trainee legal advisors are not recruited locally but by region. Their recruitment currently runs as six separate campaigns at the same time for different regions and applications can only be made to one. Current regional vacancies include London, South East, Midlands, North East, North West and Wales. The South East campaign, for example, lists 26 roles across the region, 15 in crime and 11 in family. So someone applies to a region not to a particular court. Applicants can state location preferences but there is no guarantee. Pay varies by location with a London rate and a national rate. There are no detailed publicly available statistics on their age, sex or ethnic diversity. The Institute for Government figures show 25% of all legal advisors were trainees in March 2025. That suggests a younger career workforce than the wider criminal law profession and much younger than the magistrates they are paid to advise: not necessarily a combination to ensure maximum co-operation and co-ordination.
In the light of current and possible future trends can it still be said that local magistrates are essential and available for local justice to be effective? For over a decade there is now a national bench of magistrates enabling them to sit anywhere outside their local area. 20 years ago a sitting outside the local area had to be permitted by Justices Clerk or Deputy. District Judges who sit on about 20% of cases are recruited nationally.With increasing centralisation of court administration and the changing relationship between magistrates, HMCTS and the MOJ has administrative convenience taken precedence over local accountability? Can magistrates who serve increasingly large geographical areas retain an understanding of the communities in which they exercise judicial responsibilities? Does local knowledge have any practical value in modern summary justice? Does centralisation necessarily produce a better justice system? Questions such as those arise in many organisations where the ethos seems to be "bigger is better". The NHS is a further example where there is a similar pattern. There is a potentially important distinction between the administration of justice and the delivery of justice.
The MOJ may regard larger geographical jurisdictions, centralised administration and flexible deployment of magistrates as sensible management arrangements. But that does not necessarily establish that they produce better justice. Local court management I would opine is a path which will not be re opened. Local justice by local magistrates is increasingly just a memory of those magistrates within a decade of retirement and is not going to be resurrected. It would seem that magistrates are being treated increasingly as a national rather than local resource. Their understanding of local crime patterns and community circumstances, familiarity with local policing and prosecution arrangements are now irrelevant as is the necessity of District Judges` local knowledge. Like all judges they are a national resource. It can be argued that like the senior judiciary impartiality is a necessity unlike community ties.
All the signs point to a steady increase in centralisation of what was and still is summary justice. However when and if the increased sentencing powers of the lower court become the norm the senior legal and judicial bodies will become ever more interested in outcomes and more vocal in their desire for professional jurisdiction at all levels. The only impediment to that outcome, in my opinion, is the increased financial cost that would be involved. The numbers and odds change significantly if District Judges sat without a legal advisor.
Without public confidence in a justice system there can be no democratic accountability for the governed by the governors. Various sources estimate that about 11-12 million UK citizens have a criminal record however minor. A cohort study is the clearest evidence on convictions alone. 33 per cent of males born in 1953 had been convicted of at least one standard list offence before the age of 53 and just over half of these on only one occasion. A separate MOJ bulletin estimated that about 15% of people aged 10 to 52 in 2006 had a conviction. In short a large proportion of the population has little or no knowledge or experience of how, why or where our magistrates courts operate. Translate that into practicalities and that majority won`t or doesn`t care until the fan is struck by the odour. By then it will be too late. That essential pillar for our way of life will have begun to crumble without riots, without guns and without opposition.
The MOJ may regard larger geographical jurisdictions, centralised administration and flexible deployment of magistrates as sensible management arrangements. But that does not necessarily establish that they produce better justice. Local court management I would opine is a path which will not be re opened. Local justice by local magistrates is increasingly just a memory of those magistrates within a decade of retirement and is not going to be resurrected. It would seem that magistrates are being treated increasingly as a national rather than local resource. Their understanding of local crime patterns and community circumstances, familiarity with local policing and prosecution arrangements are now irrelevant as is the necessity of District Judges` local knowledge. Like all judges they are a national resource. It can be argued that like the senior judiciary impartiality is a necessity unlike community ties.
All the signs point to a steady increase in centralisation of what was and still is summary justice. However when and if the increased sentencing powers of the lower court become the norm the senior legal and judicial bodies will become ever more interested in outcomes and more vocal in their desire for professional jurisdiction at all levels. The only impediment to that outcome, in my opinion, is the increased financial cost that would be involved. The numbers and odds change significantly if District Judges sat without a legal advisor.
















