Chris Grayling
and his cohort at Petty France just don`t stop with their press releases. If the efficient manner in which they are propagated
were typical of the efficient thinking of those behind their publication there
would be cause for a modicum of cheer.
However even in this season of goodwill I find little about the latest
offering that is anything more than a lot of hot air.
His main
innovation is to add the “punishment” element he considers missing from a third
of community sentences. These consist of
fine, unpaid work, curfew or exclusion from certain areas. The Ministry of Justice website has the
following to say about fines:-
“Fines are
the most common sentence passed at court, accounting for around two-thirds of
all sentences handed out by the criminal courts (66.5 per cent in the 12 months
ending September 2012). The fine rate is consistent with that seen in the same
period for the previous year, and has declined from a peak of 70.3 per cent in
the 12 months ending September 2004. The decline has been due to a decline in
prosecutions and subsequent conviction for summary motoring offences - the
offence type for which fines are most commonly given. The latest figure of
816,600 fines represents a decrease of 5. 2 per cent compared to the 12 months
ending September 2011, and the lowest number of fines handed out over the last
11 years.”
To quote from this blog on 21/11/2013:-
What an example of the
spin doctor`s art of obfuscation by omission. The total amount of unpaid fines
is estimated at £2 billion and rising. In addition over £130 million annually is written off because the
state cannot find or squeeze the cash from offenders. Perhaps the Secretary of
State instead of pursuing his rehabilitation of offenders by results policy
with the decimation of the probation service as a by product or playing
hardball with G4S and SERCO he would be more profitably employed in root and
branch investigation of the whole process of fines from imposition to
collection or otherwise as the case may be.
As far as “unpaid work” which is arguably the most punishing of
community requirements; with the probation service in turmoil over privatisation
the resulting omnishambles of payment by results will render any increase in
throughput a disaster.
We have all read of the scandal of the outsourcing behemoths SERCO andG4S. This blogger for one has no
confidence that an increased workload can be any more efficient than currently
is the case. Exclusion Orders are a
waste of time and an insult to intelligence.
All they are is a displacement order……NIMBYism writ large and unpleasantly.
For donkeys years various Justice Ministers have proclaimed they will be
“tough on knife crime”. It makes good
headlines but bad law. This effort will be no different.
A government which is disguising the chaos in private prisons, ruining
the probation service, decimating the police forces, throwing 10% of CPS lawyer
on the scrap heap, admitting that its own crime statistics are almost
fraudulent and generally causing despair amongst those with inside knowledge of
what`s really happening deserves
nothing but contempt for this latest attempt to paper over the cracks it has
created under the cloak of austerity.